Someone Else Has a Key to Your Home — Here Is What to Do About It
Someone Else Has a Key to Your Home — Here Is What to Do About It
Short answer: rekey the locks. It takes less than an hour, costs less than $100 per door, and immediately removes every copy of the old key from the equation — including ones you never knew existed. Here is how to think through the different situations.
This call comes in more often than people expect. It is not always a dramatic situation. Sometimes it is a former roommate who moved across town four years ago and still technically has a working key. Sometimes it is an ex-partner. Sometimes it is a contractor who did a renovation two years ago and returned the key, but the homeowner realizes they have no way to verify whether a copy was made. Sometimes it is a previous owner’s adult child who was on the original key list and nobody thought to collect from them at closing.
All of these are the same practical problem: someone has access to your home who should not. Here is how to think through the different versions.
The Former Roommate or Guest Situation
If a roommate, college-age family member, or former long-term guest still has a working key and there is no safety concern — just a change in living situation — this is the easiest version. A standard rekey resolves it completely. You do not need to notify the person, track down the key, or replace the hardware.
Rekeying does not change what the lock looks like or how it operates. It changes the internal pin configuration so the old key simply does not work anymore. If the person still has the key and tries it, the door will not open.
The Contractor or Service Provider Situation
Contractors, cleaners, dog walkers, pet sitters, and other service providers in Summerville — especially those who worked at a home repeatedly — sometimes held keys for extended periods. Standard hardware-store keys can be duplicated in under a minute. There is no way to verify whether a copy was made, and there is no way to know who might have a copy of a copy.
The standard recommendation after any working relationship ends is to rekey. This is not about distrust of a specific person — it is about the fact that a key can change hands in ways neither party intended, and rekeying is the only intervention that closes every version of that gap simultaneously.
Summerville-specific note: with so many new short-term rental properties in the area — particularly in communities near downtown and in Nexton — we regularly rekey homes after Airbnb or VRBO rental periods. A guest who duplicated a key before checkout is not common, but it is not unheard of, and a rekey between tenants is the cleanest way to ensure each new guest starts fresh.
The Ex-Partner Situation
This is the highest-urgency version and should be addressed the same day if possible. If the relationship ended on poor terms, do not wait until it is convenient. We do same-day rekeying across Summerville and all of Dorchester County, including evenings.
In this situation, also think about any secondary access points: garage door codes and keypads, smart lock PIN codes, and gate access codes for gated communities like some sections of Wescott Plantation or The Ponds. Physical rekeying handles keyed locks; the digital access points need to be addressed separately at the same time.
Rekey vs. Full Replacement — Which Makes Sense
Rekeying is the right answer in almost every case described above. It is faster, less expensive, and equally effective — the internal pin configuration change means the old key is permanently useless. Full hardware replacement is worth doing when the lock itself is damaged, when it is old enough that maintenance issues are already showing up, or when you want to use the occasion to upgrade to a smart lock that eliminates physical key copies from the equation going forward.
Need a Rekey Across Summerville Today?
Same-day rekeying available across Summerville, Nexton, Cane Bay, Ladson, and all of Dorchester County. Price confirmed before we dispatch.
Call (843) 604-6054Frequently Asked Questions
Should I rekey or fully replace the locks when an ex-partner has a key?
Rekeying is sufficient in most cases — it completely invalidates the old key at a fraction of the cost of new hardware. Full replacement only makes sense if the hardware itself is damaged, outdated, or if you want to upgrade to a smart lock at the same time.
Can a contractor who had my key make a copy without me knowing?
Yes, standard hardware-store keys can be duplicated in under a minute. There is no way to know after the fact whether a copy was made. Rekeying after any contractor relationship ends is the cleanest solution.
Is rekeying enough if I have a security concern about a specific person?
For most situations, rekeying is adequate. If there is an active safety concern — a restraining order situation or a known pattern of behavior — consider adding a door reinforcement plate and alerting a neighbor, in addition to rekeying.